11-year-old dies because parents refused medical treatment, going instead with prayer

Can we please stop the madness?


Fox News reports that 11-year-old Madeline Neumann of Weston, Wisconsin has died of a treatable form of diabetes. Why? Because her parents denied her medical treatment, going instead with prayer. This is absolute lunacy. This is worse than faith-based child abuse. Another child has died because her deluded parents felt it a better idea to put their trust in an imaginary dictator than to go with the professionals, who are known to be able to effectively treat their daughter’s condition.

The article reports that Neumann had progressively gotten sicker and sicker until she died. The autopsy determined that she died from diabetic ketoacidosis, an ailment that left her with too little insulin. She had probably been ill for approximately 30 days, enduring symptoms such as nausea, vomiting, excessive thirst, loss of appetite and weakness.

What was the girls’ parents’ explanation of the death? According to police chief Dan Vergin, Dale and Leilani Neumann attributed the death to the parents not having enough faith. I’m sorry, but no. They have it 100% backwards. She died because they had way too much faith. Well, too much faith and too dangerous an interpretation of their favourite mythology.

The parents believed that the key to healing their daughter was to keep on praying and get more and more people to help pray. For the rational individual this reasoning is ridiculous. Zero is zero. Zero multiplied by some factor is still zero. No matter how many people you get praying, you’re still accomplishing nothing. In fact, in a way you’re accomplishing less than nothing, as every second a person spends doing nothing (i.e., praying) is a second they could have spent doing something (e.g., CALLING A DOCTOR!).

But wait! This may not be over! Doctor Mom believes that the girl still could be resurrected. Well halellujah! Don’t anybody call the Neumanns, they’re busy having a crash prayer session, you can be assured.

When I first heard of this story, I figured the family were either Christian Scientists or Jehovah’s Witnesses. According to the police chief, they do not attend an organized church or participate in an organized religion. Rather, they have a small Bible study of a few people.

The girl was not an only child. She has three siblings ranging in age from 13 to 16. These children are being left with the family. The police chief said that there are no signs of abuse, and hence no reason to remove them.

In a secular nation which presumably aspires toward some degree of sanity, should a family that has just knowingly allowed their child to die in the name of their religion be deemed fit parents? Even if none of their other children acquire a potentially dangerous affliction, at minimum these parents will be teaching their children that prayer is the answer and medicine is not. This sort of teaching puts these children and the children of these children at significant unnecessary risk.

Hat Tip: Mark Robinson of the Humanist Globe

65 Responses to “11-year-old dies because parents refused medical treatment, going instead with prayer”
  1. Just un-bleeping-believable! I’m so furious that this goes on in our society and that you can use religion as an excuse for behavior that should be considered criminal.

    I am all for freedom of religion and beliefs, however the protection of the children in our society needs to be a priority. You are correct in that leaving the rest of the children with these parents poses a danger, not only to their physical safety, but to their mental safety. These children are right now being brain washed that prayer is going to solve any problem they will ever face.

    There should be criminal consequences for the parents and the children removed from the home. Why is it we need to get a license to drive a car or to go fishing or to own a pet? Yet we need no qualifications or proof of responsibility when we have children? Something is upside down about how society places a higher value on the freedom of adults, over the value of the safety of children.

  2. Stoobs says:

    Absolutely. This is child abuse, pure and simple – the parents should not just be losing their kids, they should be standing trial for manslaughter.

  3. David Yolleck says:

    This is not as rare, or as remarkable, as it should be. Every several years, I encounter an article about parents who pray an insulin-dependent child to death. The almost acceptable sort of faith-based ignorance that this kind of event is grounded upon warrants vigorous prosecution. Notwithstanding the First Amendment, I would be pleased to see public schools teaching methods of thought that could render persons less susceptible to such nonsense.

  4. iris blonde says:

    This is completely unacceptable!!! As the mother of a wonderful Type 1 Juvenile Diabetic daughter, there IS NO REASON why Madeline Neumann, had to suffer for even 1 second of her life. Her parents directly caused her suffering due to their blatent ignorance.
    “In the name of religion” or rather “hiding behind religion” is NEVER an excuse.
    I am outraged and deeply saddened by what society has deemed acceptable parental behaviour.
    May we never have even one drop of ignorance when it comes to another human being’s precious life.

  5. Juanito Epstein says:

    When this happens to people integrated with society there is an outcry (as there should be) but in the Amish community these crimes would go unnoticed. Who is speaking for the these people? There is no media in Amish communities to report child abuse like this, so who is representing their voiceless and unnoticed?

  6. L. Ron Brown says:


    I had never even considered Amish communities in this regard. As for your question, I have no idea.

  7. Derek says:

    Are the parents facing any legal charges?

    Overall this is one sad case. Couldn’t the courts have stepped in to look out for this child’s well-being? It seems to me that if claiming “religion” gets these sick people off the hook for essentially killing their daughter, then anyone could claim “religion” in any situation and not face any consequences.

    Just my opinion.

  8. L. Ron Brown says:


    To my understanding, they’re not facing charges.

    I’m thinking that the special treatment to religion in this case is strongly influenced by the combination of lack of malice, passivity (rather than active killing), and the idea of parental entitlement to make decisions concerning their kids. Obviously, people wouldn’t be able to play the faith card for stoning a woman to death on her father’s doorstep for not being a virgin on her wedding night, or for killing an apostate (well, they could get away with this in certain parts of the Islamic world….).

  9. April says:

    These people should be facing murder charges. I’m sorry, but their actions go beyond simply manslaughter. They knew that their child had a treatable disease, but they chose to do nothing. They sat there for at least 30 days and watched her dying literally in front of their eyes, and did nothing. They knowingly and willingly let her die for absolutely no reason.

    These people had the audacity to actually say that they never expected her to die during prayer. What the hell did they expect? Well, apparently the mother thinks that the kid can be resurrected. But, seriously!! What did they expect? Did they expect her to jump up and proclaim that she was magically cured? Please!!

    There is no excuse and no defense that could ever justify what they did. They essentially murdered their child, and they deserve to be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. And while people are at it, the other kids need to be removed from the home. If this wasn’t a clear case of abuse, I don’t know what is!!

  10. Stoobs says:

    As I understand it, allowing someone to die through your inaction is the definition of manslaughter, while murder requires that you actively seek to bring about the death. So, letting someone drown is manslaughter – holding them under is murder. I could be wrong about this though – I’m no lawyer.

  11. April says:

    Well okay, under the law it would be manslaughter. If they’re charged with manslaughter it had better be voluntary manslaughter because they knowingly and willfully let their daughter die by not getting her medical attention. They may not have known that she had diabetes. But they knew she was sick, and they did nothing!! They are beyond negligent here.

    I, for one, have zero sympathy for them. The only people that I feel sorry for are that little girl, the relative who tried to check on her welfare, and her siblings because she’s dead and they’re left with parents who did nothing to save their sister.

  12. breadandsham says:

    I’m certainly glad that humanists aren’t allowed to make laws by pure moral subjectivity.

  13. L. Ron Brown says:

    Bread and Sham:

    First off, moral subjectivism is not a necessity of humanism any more than pretend moral objectivism is a product of religion. The Golden Rule is a good idea, regardless of where it came from. And we can establish rules based on principles such as the golden rule and considerations of what sort of society would develop if certain things were allowed (e.g., Would a society of chaos or fear result? That would be bad. Are we preventing someone from living a life that they want to live simply because we find it offensive? Would we like it if someone did that to us?).

    Secondly, I think it’s bullshit that we have deluded religious people who think that their views on morality are somehow at a higher level than those who they *admit* are the concoction of humanity.

    Humanism does not necessitate moral subjectivity any more than religion entails pretend moral objectivism.

  14. aaron says:

    I agree that this is a delusional and moronic action by the parents. But I also wonder why such a hardcore religious belief precludes the use of medicine. With some Amish, at least their beliefs permeate their whole lives and show some consistency: no electricity, phones, cars, modern medicine, etc. Was that the case with these people? If not, why would they think God would allow such technological advancements as microwaves, electricity and automobiles but not medicine? And furthermore, if God is omnipotent and all-knowing and controls the fate of people, wouldn’t He have had His hand in advancing modern medicine for us to use? I imagine thinking isn’t a priority for such zealots.

  15. Stoobs says:

    The real problem is that the exact same thing goes on at a much larger scale. Much of the willingness of Christians to ignore major problems like global warming, overpopulation, vanishing natural resources, and so forth is their steadfast belief that god will look after them as long as they pray. This belief is held even in the face of massive evidence to the contrary, and gives them license to completely ignore any problem, no matter how dangerous.

    They are a danger to themselves and others, and probably deserve their own page in the DSM IV. The fact that they don’t get one is solely a result of the special treatment given to religion.

  16. Elizabeth says:

    While these people have obviously made an extremely bad choice and have cost their daughter her life, this article has so many things wrong with it, as do many of you in your responses to it. I know it doesn’t do any good to say so, but I’m sure there are many facts left out, and obviously the whole story was completely biased and accusatory, even stooping to make fun of Christianity as a whole based on this one set of events.

    For this to happen is terrible, and these people probably should not have children, but I assure you, very few Christians make life decisions like this based completely on faith… Christians are not idiots, whatever you may think. Although not everything about the religion can be proven, neither can it be disproved… and many intelligent people still have faith. There are many valuable arguments explaining that, but that’s beside the point.

    I do agree that anyone who blindly trusts God to handle their (and the world’s) problems, is sadly misled, never in the Bible (to my knowledge) does it instruct anyone to do so… in fact the opposite “God helps those who help themselves”. Prayer is not meant to be the sole action taken to solve a situation… neither is prayer pointless as mentioned in the passage above. I love debate so bring it on. I realize this comment is just a bit random and maybe contradictory, but I’m in a hurry so I don’t have time to try harder.

    • chuck peters says:

      I appreciate your effort to defend the much more mainstream Christian position as you did in this comment. However, the Bible never says that “God helps those who help themselves.” This is a very often quoted statement that gets attributed to the Bible. Even some preachers use it. There is much more that can be discussed that this article brings up. But in the end those whose hearts are filled with darkness will never see truth through the eyes of faith. Faith will at times lead a man to do things that are not normal. Abraham willing to kill his only son. But in those cases there is usually a very specific and substantive revelation from God.
      I believe that we have become way too dependent on the ‘god of moderen medicine’ here in America. At the same time, I bleieve that we should take reasonable measures to allow God to heal us throught the wisdom that He gave to men and women in the medical feild. This is where faith and reason meet in the daily routine of life. Paul tells Timothy to take a little wine for the sake of his health. Men had discovered the medicinal valure of wine and Paul was telling Timothy to utilize that knowledge.
      Much more that could be said but time does not permit.
      keep up the good work.

  17. Fay says:

    While I don’t excuse their actions I believe that their belief that God would heal Madeline was accurate. I say this because I believe that God will heal as well. The difference between me and them is that I know God uses others to carry out His healing. It’s unfortunate that they misinterpreted the Bible because the result is the death of their beautiful daughter.

    • In God we trust says:

      What the bible does tell us about healing can be found in John chapter 5, The man had been sick for 38 years when jesus healed him. The man was healed because of his faith so jesus said to him take up hy pallet and walk. Although it was the sabbath Jesus is not limited to do miricles. However just as God has given us a choice to serve him and accept jesus for forgiveness of our sins he has given us common sense and as individuals we are to use that common sense. The problem with many christians today they are like the jews in this passage who thought Jesus was wrong, they have it all figured out for God and allow themselves to be judge over everyone else. God has given us medical knowledge and expects us to use it and as a last resort when all hope is lost then in jesus can we be healed. Faith is by hearing and hearing by the word of God.God says, “I am the Lord who heals you.” Exodus 15:26

      “I will take away sickness from among you. . .” Exodus 23:25,26

      “He forgives all my sins and heals ALL my Diseases.” Psalm 103:3

      “I will give you back your health again and heal your wounds.” Jeremiah 30:17

      “The Lord will remove from you all sickness. . .” Deuteronomy 7:15

      “My counsel shall stand, and I WILL do ALL my pleasure.: Isaiah 46:10

      “Yes, I have spoken it. I will also bring it to Pass. I have purposed it. I will also do it.” Isaiah 46:11

      “God cannot lie.” Titus 1:2

      “I am the Lord: I will speak, and the word that I shall speak shall come to pass. Ezekiel 12:25

      When Jesus was on earth, He NEVER referred anyone to a Physician

      God needs no middle men. When Jesus was on earth, when someone came to Him for healing, He never referred the person to Luke, the “Physician.” Jesus healed the person directly and personally. And He healed him either with His Word – which we have today, in the form of the Bible – or He healed him with natural methods – clay, water, etc.

      Jesus NEVER used drugs, although we know that some types of drugs were available

      • Agnostic Scholar says:

        Dearest In God We Trust,

        You are an idiot reading from a 2000 year old book written by nomadic shepherds. If Jesus of the “buy-bull” existed, he was a prophet, not the son of the xtian god. May nothing happen to one of your loved ones. That will be the beginning of you realizing that your god does not exist. Or, if he exists, he does not care.

      • Bigbob says:

        You stupid F***!!!! God does not administer insulin!! Parents and carers do that!!
        But if your so hung up on religion does that big book you read not state, ” i have given you all the seed bearing plants and herbs to use”. The state should have interveined removed the child from its home, and jailed or given lethal injection to the little girls parents. (Slightly harsh but everyone messes around and it all gets messed up with red tape!)
        Does that big book not also state an eye for an eye. If you can even justify through religous BRAINWASHING what the parents done you need to have a look at yourself. They stood and watched their child die!!!!!
        As the parent of an 11 year old boy with type 1 my priority in life is to ensure his health and wellbeing, it is a medical fact that it is a treatable condition which is my responsibility and if it was treatable by going to church then thats what i would do, anything to to keep him healthy. I hope for anyone touched by diabetes that medicine moves forward and they can cure diabetes
        I do hope for miracles in the cure of this but i will be putting my faith in medical science, fact.

        In god we trust i am angry at your post, may your balls turn square and fester at the corners.

    • TruthSayer says:

      There is no difference between you and them. If your God exists then why would he let children die out of confusion? These people obviously had faith. They were just stupid/misguided. So if God knows they have faith and he is all powerful then why didn’t he intervene to save this little girl? Answer that. He knows the parents were doing what they thought was best, based on his word, right? He, apparently, knows everything. Go ahead and do your mental gymnastics and make another excuse for your God. For someone that is supposed to be all powerful and all knowing, a lot of idiotic meaningless deaths are allowed to happen. But keep telling yourself whatever lies you need to keep your faith going in spite of all logic and reason.

  18. Stoobs says:

    “Is any among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the church; and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord: and the prayer of faith shall save him that is sick, and the Lord shall raise him up; and if he have committed sins, it shall be forgiven him.” (James 5:14-15 ASV)

    Christian literalists are committed to the truth of this passage. Think about that for a moment. If you believe in the literal inerrancy of the bible, then you believe that this verse is completely accurate, more valid than medical science. You are committed to that belief, and to ignore it would be to turn your back on your faith. It is precisely christianity and faith in the bible that has killed this child.

    The fact that some christians are not sincere enough in their faith to leave the healing up to god is not a defense of christianity. It just tells us that some people have enough brains to set aside faith and trust facts when dealing with important stuff. But get it straight, if you don’t believe that god will heal you when you’re prayed over, you believe the bible lies.

    It’s true that I can’t disprove the existence of god. But I also can’t disprove the existence of unicorns, pixies, two headed crocodile demons, or winged foxes. Why is it that a person with faith in god is defended, but a person with faith in any of those other things (all of which are more plausible than god) is ridiculed?

    Faith is just wishful thinking with a flashy paintjob.

    • Nic says:

      I completely agree. It’s the same with aliens. While I can’t say for sure, there is without a doubt more proof for aliens than God, and yet most people ridicule those who believe in aliens. Yet, they believe in a bearded man floating in the sky? Lol

  19. kristy says:

    i agree with most that say that these parents acted irresponsibly… what is wrong with having faith AND seeking medical attention when needed! i’m sorry but not allowing people to help your sick child is just… wrong!!!

  20. arlywn says:

    scary, scary. I think this was handled entirely too wrong. Wrong once by the parents for believing in prayer over medicine. did they ever think maybe gods way of helping her was by providing people who could?

    And wrong by the police in believing the same absolute lunacy that the parents have done nothing wrong. But I guess two wrongs = one right now?

  21. Erika says:

    My eleven year old niece has Type 1 Diabetes – she is strong, healthy, beautiful and bright. She also injects insulin 4 times a day and watches her diet. We pray for a cure , but rejoice in the treatment and dedicated Doctors available to us.

    This poor girl died a painful death. This is not child abuse, it’s murder.

  22. breadandsham says:

    You wrote: “Humanism does not necessitate moral subjectivity any more than religion entails pretend moral objectivism.”

    Most of the discussion happening here is about how criminal the Neumanns are. I’m in full agreement that they made a tragic misrepresentation of their faith, since there are numerous examples in Scripture where faith is paired up with action for results different from that of faith alone. However, the name-calling is coming from narrow and limited perspectives.

    Christianity, or any faith that recognized the Bible as authoritative, is by definition, objective. Therefore, it necessitates objectivity.

    Secondly, humanism by definition places faith within the individual as autonomous and independent of any outside source. Therefore, humanism necessitates relativity. Your well trained in psychology. This should not be a foreign concept to you.

  23. Stoobs says:

    As I have already said, the Neumanns did not misrepresent their faith – the bible explicitly claims that god will heal any illness in response to prayer and anointment with oil.

    And humanists are in no way required to accept moral relativism. They are only required to ground their morality in something human. Aristotle, Kant, Locke, Rousseau, and a variety of others have put forward humanistic theories of morality which ground it in a variety of places other than a divine will. And that’s just off the top of my head.

    Gods and holy books are not a solution to immorality, they are an invitation for weird, idiosyncratic, and ultimately self serving moral codes to be grounded in the vague, arbitrary writings that have been repeatedly mistranslated and reinterpreted in the light of prevailing political and economic interests.

  24. Rebecca says:

    BadBoy Bill gave a website: stevenspoint.com/police/sexoffenders/daleneumann…anyway, this man is NOT Kara’s father (I knew her parents a while before she was even born), and this is not the same person. Dale is a loving husband and father who made a grave mistake not knowing Kara was deathly ill, not this sex offender who you have listed. Get your facts straight before listing stuff you know nothing about…these parents are suffering and have to live with Kara’s death for the rest of their lives!

  25. L. Ron Brown says:

    Who is Kara?

    I think you have the wrong Neumann in mind here.

  26. “According to the police chief, they do not attend an organized church or participate in an organized religion. Rather, they have a small Bible study of a few people”.
    ~~~~~~Why is Christianity being blamed? Just because a person subscribes to “faith” of some sort, does not automatically deem them a “Christian”. They believed in “Spooky” Religion. The extremist kind that gives every religion a bad name. I believe in prayer. I do. I pray. I also pray to a God who gives us many tools and several rules. One is called Medicine. Another is Common Sense. Another is a commandment not to commit murder then dare claim “faith” or hide behind His name to justify it. That’s crap. Their daughter died because the parents have poor mentality. This is the epitomy of a senseless death due to neglect and nothing more.

  27. It doesn’t take 30 days to figure out someone, especially a child needs medical attention when they are suffering with diabetes…even if you don’t know its diabetes! Unless that person is a complete moron, that person ought to know it’s SOMETHING! It doesn’t matter who the father is, that child did not get the medical attention she needed. Period. Who lets their child suffer that long before getting professional help!? Please! I am up to my eyeballs with defenseless children being neglected, mistreated, abused and murdered by caregivers of any title all because the very ones who are supposed to protect them simply don’t. That is not proper parenting. Biological or not. Faith or none. Heck, atheist have physicians. The parents need their heads examined.

  28. L. Ron Brown says:

    Why is Christianity being blamed? I’d say that what is blamed is really 1) the parents, and 2) the social convention of giving way too much respect to religious beliefs. We can agree on 1, so I’ll not talk about it. As for 2, if our society wasn’t so handcuffed by its committed to respect religious belief and practices this probably would not have happened, and if it did, these parents would have had their remaining children taken away from them, would have been put on trial, and would have served as an example to every other pair of parents may have acted similarly in the future.
    I’ve said it before: respect for religious beliefs is really a matter of democratic bullying. If only a few people believe in a particular creation and moral mythology, there is no pressure within society to respect (or, rather, submit to) these beliefs. However, if the community of believers grows and develops a lobby, the rest of society is lobbied into pretending that these beliefs are now somehow more respectable than they were when there were fewer believers. If when there were only a handful of believers something like the Neumann situation had happened, people probably woulda treated the incident as prove positive that this is a dangerous cult. The parents would have had their children removed, possibly had jail time, and so on and on. If there was only a single parent and he/she did to their kid what the Neumann’s did to Madeleine because of a parallel belief that they held alone, society would have deemed the parent to be mentally unfit to take care of a child and probably them self and probably would have been committed to a psychiatric care facility for some period of time and then eventually let out, but with a short-leash and monitoring.

  29. from Weston says:

    Prosecutors and police might soon provide answers on the fate of a town of Weston couple whose 11-year-old child died after they chose prayer instead of medical attention.


  30. Jason says:

    Have these people ever heard or read their bibles. God doesn’t help those that don’t help themselves. I know that and I’m not religious, and don’t tell me the bible doesn’t say this. When David killed Goliath he acted for himself by faith in God. He didn’t just stand there like a stump and let God do everything. Holy people never cease to amaze me on how truly stupid and incompetent they can be. I think they should follow the bible on this one; eye for an eye. Give them the chair.

  31. Equalist says:

    What I find odd in all of this is you hear about the children who are sick and dying and the courts force their parents to repeat common treatments that haven’t worked for that particular child over homeopathic remedies that have shown promise, and remove children from the care of their parents for refusing, yet here we have a child who was not being treated at all, and she was allowed to die without receiving medical treatment while her parents face no real punishment, and the other children remain in the home to suffer the same consequences should they ever become seriously ill. The only real difference I see here is that this child died in the name of religion rather that “This makes him more comfortable and it seems to help” Does anyone else find this disturbing?

  32. Mothball says:

    “……..particular child over homeopathic remedies that have shown promise”

    Homeopathy and the memory of water have never been proven, in fact ALL double blind trials done on it show it doesn’t work. ALSO homeopathy defies ALL the known laws of physics especially the law of mass action. Just read the bottles they will say stuff like 1 atom in 10^32, which is impossible. The whole theory relies on water “some how” “remembering” it once had an atom of pollen or whatever in it, this is even dumber than hollow earth theory.

    P.S the parents should be thrown in jail for the rest of there lives! However people who resort to homeopathy are JUST as bad as both sets of parents are relying on unsubstantiated fantasy and religion wether that be Christianity or new ageism.

    “since the least amount of a substance in a solution is one molecule, a 30C solution would have to have at least one molecule of the original substance dissolved in a minimum of 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 molecules of water. This would require a container more than 30,000,000,000 times the size of the Earth” – Robert L. Park, former executive director of the American Physical Society

  33. Another diabetic says:

    Actually, I suspect that if/when the moronic parents meet God, the diskussion will be something like:
    “God, why didnt You cure or help her when we begged You?”
    “What are you talking about? I sent doctors and insulin for her help, but You refused my gifts, sent them away and let her die painfully.. (and about that last thing, please go into that elevator you see over there and press the button marked “Down/H”)”

  34. tpkatsa says:

    I wrote a little something about this on my blog here:


  35. Emily And Kara And Megan says:

    They killed there daughter by refusing treatment. Wheres there god now.

  36. Jana Fedon says:

    I know this thread is old but I just came upon it and had to “talk” with everyone who is bashing Christianity here…this child died due to negligence of her parents, NOT because they were praying for her but because they refused to see the answer to their prayers staring them in the face: ie: doctors, insulin, etc. Faith isnt trusting God to DO everything but for Him to show us the way He wants us to live. He did show them, they ignored it. To say publicly in this forum, as the originator of this thread states that they were “trusting in an imaginary dictator” and implying that God is made of mythology are two of the saddest statements I have ever read! Dear R.B. , what a sad existence you must have with the end of your life resulting in complete nothingness. But, you will have an eye opening event upon that death…there IS a Creator and at the risk of sounding like a fanatic who you will only laugh at and about I will tell you that I know this to be true. Once you have faith it is only made even more abundantly clear what the Truth is…I will pray for you, even though you find that laughable, that you will one day find your Father/Creator and know that your public defacement of Him was the most ludicrous part of this whole discussion. As for the parents, they will find their own judgement as He deals with them on His own, this is not for us to do.

  37. clancy says:

    I thought that one of the earlier commenters had a good point. God cures through others. That girl was supposed to live, God did hear their prayers and provided the medical help to save her. God has to work through the limitations of the physical plane, because that’s how things on this level work. God knows this so he answers their prayers in a very practical way, providing the caregivers and the science to save the girls life.

    Alas, the parents were expecting something a bit more flashy. Their let their child down horribly. The suffering involved in dying from diabetes is t-r-u-l-y awful. But noone needs to go through that suffering..God provides us with doctors who he works through, whether they know it or not.

    The parents are not fit to raise children, alas.

  38. Marc Whilden says:

    This is what happens when you have too much faith. This girl died because the family tried to pray her illness away. I wish this was the only example but it isnt’ theres more. I understand that the world will have their gods and I do believe in tolerance but the wold is becoming less tolerant to others. People should stand up to people who want to take my rights and liberties.

  39. Anonymous says:

    Ill call her parents killers they should be arrested. If they aren’t it lets other parents know its okay to kill their children by not seeing a doctor its abuse.

  40. 0gga says:

    Natural selection IS happening…Except the parents should have gone instead of the girl 😦

  41. iç giyim says:

    Howdy! I just wish to give you a huge thumbs up for your great info you have got here on this post. I will be returning to your site for more soon.

  42. medikal says:

    After I originally commented I seem to have clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now whenever a comment is added I get 4 emails with the exact same comment. Is there an easy method you can remove me from that service? Appreciate it!

  43. medikal says:

    After I originally left a comment I seem to have clicked on the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now whenever a comment is added I receive 4 emails with the exact same comment. Perhaps there is a way you are able to remove me from that service? Thanks!

  44. Highly descriptive article, I liked that bit.
    Will there be a part 2?

  45. Ardis Gacek says:

    All legal issues aside, what sickens me most is the suffering that the child went through. As a nurse with 23 years of experience, and a 45 year old healthy woman who has had diabetes since age 9, this strikes very close to home and makes me think back about how sick I was leading up to my diagnosis. Basically, when you are in diabetic ketoacidosis eventually your heart will stop because your serum potassium becomes so high. This is not the worst of it. The worst part of it is the constant vomiting and extreme thirst the precedes this. The vomiting and thirst are so bad that you cannot hold even water down, but crave it anyway. I remember being so thirsty that I’d just drink anyway, and within seconds of swallowing, the water would come up still ice cold. The “cotton mouth” is unbearable and so bad it is hard to open your mouth and the horrible muscle cramps seize your body with pain. As a mother, it is unfathomable that any parent could watch their child go through this and take no aggressive action regardless of their religion. certainly their sanity is questionable.

  46. Reena says:

    Last month, it was my birthday, the anniversary of my late husband’s death, and a time when I experienced another loss in my family. I was in total depression also because the gentleman I had been seeing for nearly a year decided to cut ties with me. All this happened at the same time, and my heart was broken. Then I found Ekaka email: ekakaspelltemple@yahoo.com and all my luck turned around – especially because the master did a wonderful spell of Love for me and my dearest companion, who decided he had made a terrible mistake by leaving me. We even took a much-needed vacation. It meant the world to me, and I have you to thank for it. I send you Prayers.

  47. Mando says:

    God isn’t an imaginary figure. He is in fact real. I’m a Catholic but i know that God isn’t supposed to do everything

  48. Sandra Chali says:

    When I married my husband I was already pregnant and so I didn’t have a job. He had a really good job though so I was able to stay home and take care of our son when it was born. When we had our second child we moved to a bigger house, but then strange things started to happen. Things would fly off the walls and doors would slam at night. Our oldest son talked about seeing figures and hearing voices. We consulted a medium and they said the house was haunted. After living there about a year more with only minor occurrences we moved out. That was when the bad luck started to happen. Everything started to fail, with my husband’s job, our money and our luck in general. I went back to the same medium and they told me that a spirit had followed me and placed a curse upon me for disturbing it and not being respectful in the previous house. He tried to remove it but was unable. The misfortune kept going on and getting more severe as I tried to search out someone to break the curse. But when I found Dr.Azonto spell he finally did it. Things started turning around almost immediately after he cast the spell and have been great from there! This was really a miracle for us, thank you . azontotemple@yahoo.com spell from the bottom of my heart!
    Posted by. miss Sandra Chali

  49. Anonymous says:

    That’s murder. What mother or father would won’t to see there love dead just because of what they fell what about what the little girl fells did anyone ask her before she died???. I fell if the child is supported by the hospital or Dr. Who knows whats best for the child should be able to save that child not watch her die The 11 year old still should have been treated to save her life, again I stress this is murder because people can be dirty and don’t give a damm and get insurance off there children, a burse plays a big part in this case, love just don’t let you watch your child die if you can save them. That’s a blessing. The child of protection service why they dint step in they should of said something, they protected other children who have been close to death why not this 11 year old.

  50. Barbara Brandt says:

    So children will be removed when abused but not if they die because they were not treated for a disease. My friend in the 1950’s, Jan went to my sunday school in GlendaleCalifornia and one day she was dead. I was 10. she was 10. I demanded we go to Forest Lawn Cemetary and get her out of there! She was good and God did not kill children. I beat up her sister on the play ground and was sent to home. I hated my religion every day after that. Christian Science. I found out my Grandmother had dominated to the degree that I was given NO medical care EVER. I suffered many bad illnesses in my room. I went looking for this guy God. I became a dare devil and amost got killed. I was sure he would find me if he was really there. We need to solve this crisis for children. they have Civil Rights and one of those rights is to be protected from those that would refuse them medical care if they are sick. There is truly something sociopathic in those that are so fanatical that they refuse science and say we “must know the truth.” Development for children makes it impossible for this abstract reasoning and choice. Oh yes, they do not accept the most common science, even that that is required for being a teacher and understanding learning theory so that we teach certain subjects as the brain developes. Instead, we should teach abstract concepts like a supreme being to a two year old. Amazingly ignorant and no child should be subjected to this ignorance. There is one thing I want to say about Mary Baker Eddy. She did not put forth this doctrine as it is taught today. She was an abolitionist and worked diligently to save slaves and knew first hand the ugliness of human behavior. She believed in God but she also knew the need to use the law to save people from harm. If she did this, then those that think they have no obligation to save their children from harm are absurd. Her home is preserved in Boston for her good work to help slaves and President Lincoln and she were good friends. She looked at the devil in the face and she knew man had choices and that man had to make these choices and not rely on God.

  51. Monique Curry says:

    Monique Curry ,

Check out what others are saying...
  1. […] This results in deaths and prolonged illnesses, usually for children on a regular basis, such as here, here , here and here.  I feel most for the brainwashed (if they live long […]

  2. […] who refused to take their child to the hospital for religious reasons? Was it cancer?… I forget Here's one on diabetes. […]

  3. […] I’m perfectly willing to admit that religion has a role for many people in their personal lives and perhaps in their communities, but that is where the line must be drawn. Our founding documents and the rudimentary principles of pluralism and civil society demand that government must be neutral on the question of religion, at best. Of course, I think that it is totally valid to examine a candidate’s moral dispositions when determining whether or not that candidate should be elected (Mitt Romney’s Mormonism for example, or Rick Santorum’s alarming and reactionary form of Catholicism). This is especially true if the principles of a candidate’s religion openly advocate actions that break the law- like parents who deny their children medical care because it “violates their faith”, even when their children are dying. Here’s an example…oh and here’s another one. […]

  4. […] see, these are rhetorical questions that can’t be answered with facts, but with one’s opinion.  One’s opinion based on factors such as religious upbringing, environment, society, mental […]

  5. […] life to make the PTSD go away. Religion cannot cure a medical disease. People have tried that. It fails every time. PTSD is not a “lack of Jesus” disease. It is a medical disease. It requires […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: